Dear Grammar Maven,
When abbreviating state names for our website, I think it looks better to use the periods after the letters (N.C.) but I have been told this is old fashioned and wrong. Help!
Signed,
Aggravated Abbreviator
Dear Aggravated:
The Grammar Maven feels your pain. She personally cringes at the elimination of the Oxford comma. Alas, you are dashed between the Scylla and Charybdis of current American usage.
1. The trend toward brevity and simplification
The Grammar Maven will spare you the lecture on how prepositional phrases have been replaced by adjectives or how the ends of adjectives now drop like little flies (from "Korean" War to “Iraq” War, for example). It makes the Grammar Maven shudder.
For whatever reason—USA Today or the Internet (LOL, brb)—English is getting shortened and simplified. In the ‘60s when the USPO’s new sorting machines required an accurate uniform destination code, ZIP Codes and two-letter state abbreviations were born. Which is why we now write FL instead of Fla. or NY instead of N.Y.
Do you really object to NYC, UCLA, NFL or even UNCG? Soon we will all wonder why anyone used periods in the first place.
Though “N.C.” is still technically correct, it is bucking the trend.
2. House style
Alas, those whose profession is not language were often, as innocent wide-eyed babes, convinced by a frowning, lemon-sucking, pointer-wielding English teacher that there is only one right way to do things.
T’ain’t so, my dears.
Numerous matters of grammar, spelling, and punctuation are arbitrary. Web site or website? Role play, role-play, or roleplay? Even, alas, your Grammar Maven's beloved Oxford comma.
Every publisher (including Web) creates a style for their house that answers these questions, because a hallmark of professional publishing is CONSISTENCY. It divides the pros from those who crank out newsletters in the basement on their ditto machines.
Your organization uses “NC.” It is your house style. That is the one you should use.
If it is any consolation the Grammar Maven herself had to bow on the issue of capitalizing “Internet.”
Sometimes you just have to take one for the team.